2004 Peace Medal Nickel – This limited-edition nickel, featuring the Peace Medal, can fetch over $1,000 in mint condition due to its rarity.
2005 Bison Nickel – Featuring a buffalo on the reverse, this design was produced for only one year, making it a valuable find for collectors today.
2009 Jefferson Nickel (Reverse Proof) – With a special reverse proof design, this coin is now highly sought after, worth significantly more than face value.
1997 Nickel with Full Steps – A 1997 nickel with a well-defined "Full Steps" on the Monticello building can fetch up to several hundred dollars from collectors.
2004 "W" Nickel – The "W" mint mark nickels, produced at the West Point Mint, are extremely rare and can be worth over $100 depending on condition.
2006 "D" Satin Finish Nickel – A special satin finish produced for collectors, these are rarer than regular circulation coins and can command high prices.
1999 Wide AM Nickel – This error coin features a rare "Wide AM" misprint on the reverse, making it one of the most sought-after nickels from the late '90s.